A photo of a bungalow with white render and solar panels on the roof.

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

Published on: November 17, 2026

Written by: Mark Freeman

Do You Really Save Money with a Heat Pump?

I’ve installed many air source heat pumps across the South of England and seen firsthand how they deliver comfort, lower bills, and major carbon reductions – but only when designed and installed properly.

As I’ve unfortunately witnessed during many a callout in my decade and a half in the industry, a poorly planned and installed system can, and usually does, underperform, leading to higher running costs than a modern gas boiler and even a worse carbon footprint in some cases.

Here is a clear, honest guide for homeowners.

Why Heat Pumps Can Save Money, But Often Don’t Without the Right Setup

Typically, heat pumps are 300 to 400 percent efficient (often quoted as a seasonal coefficient of performance (SCOP) of 3 to 4 plus in well-designed systems), meaning they deliver 3 to 4 plus units of heat for every unit of electricity used to run the compressor and other electrical components. A good gas boiler reaches around 90 percent efficiency.

Electricity costs more per kWh than gas, so the efficiency advantage only turns into real savings with low flow temperatures, good insulation and proper system design, allowing the heat pump to run at the optimal temperatures where this efficiency can be achieved.

In the milder climate of the South Coast where I’m based, heat pumps often perform particularly well compared to colder northern regions, with strong potential for savings when installed correctly – a reason I have long supported the technology.

Without upgrades to existing systems, however, a heat pump may run at lower efficiency (for example, a SCOP closer to 2.5 to 3), making it comparable to or more expensive than gas in some homes, especially those with newer, efficient gas boilers. Poor installations have given heat pumps a mixed reputation, but the technology excels when implemented correctly.

The Critical Importance of Low Flow Temperatures

Heat pumps produce warmth most efficiently at lower temperatures (ideally 35 to 45°C flow) compared to boilers (60 to 80°C plus). Your heat distribution system – pipework, radiators or underfloor heating – must be suited to this for maximum efficiency.

Think of it like this: a heat pump is like a marathon runner, efficient over long distances at a steady, moderate pace. A gas boiler is a sprinter, powerful in short, intense bursts but wasteful if forced to run a marathon.

If you make the marathon runner sprint (high flow temperatures), they tire quickly and use far more energy. Larger radiators or underfloor heating give the runner a smooth path, allowing steady, low-effort performance for optimal efficiency and lower bills.

  • Radiator upgrades: Existing radiators (if designed correctly in the first place) often lack enough surface area for lower temperatures. Larger panels, additional radiators, or aluminium ones for better heat transfer are frequently needed. Changing from 65 to 45°C, for example, requires around a threefold increase in surface area for the same output.
  • Underfloor heating: Ideal for heat pumps, operating at very low temperatures (30 to 40°C) with even heat distribution over a large surface area.
  • Pipework: Larger pipes or adjustments may be required in older systems to reduce resistance and support better flow at lower temperatures. You have less energy density, so will likely need more volume to transport the same amount of energy to its ultimate destination.

These changes help maintain a high SCOP, often making running costs lower than gas (especially on dedicated heat pump tariffs with off-peak rates – something for later discussion) and delivering even stronger benefits when replacing oil or LPG.

Proper Siting of External Units

The outdoor unit needs careful placement for performance, noise and longevity:

  • Ensure good airflow: Leave clear space around the unit (typically 300mm plus from walls, and considerably more in front of the fan). Avoid enclosed spaces, which cause the unit to recycle its own cold air and drop performance.
  • Consider neighbours: Position away from bedrooms and windows to minimise noise (units must meet permitted noise limits at boundaries). Anti-vibration mounts and flexible hoses help, but they are no substitute for location.
  • Avoid flood-prone areas: Or raise the unit if needed. Check permitted development rules (usually no planning permission is required, but exceptions apply for listed buildings or conservation areas).

A well-sited unit runs more efficiently and quietly, with fewer defrost cycles in our relatively temperate winters.

Insulation Upgrades: The Foundation for Efficiency

Why would you keep pouring more water into a bucket with holes in without first considering plugging the holes?

Insulation reduces heat demand, allowing the heat pump to run the heating with lower outputs and temperatures for higher efficiency. Many homes already have decent levels, but upgrades maximise savings and comfort.

Common upgrades include:

  • Loft insulation (to 270mm plus): A quick win that prevents massive roof heat loss. Low installation cost, or self-install.
  • Cavity wall insulation: For suitable properties. Done properly, it will not cause the damp often associated with it.
  • Solid wall insulation (internal or external): For older homes with solid walls. This is best done by a specialist and is not always possible.
  • Floor insulation and draught proofing: Seals gaps around windows, doors and floors. Lifting floors to insulate below is not always practical or viable due to cost and disruption.
  • Windows and doors: Double or triple glazing where needed.

The bottom line is that better insulation lowers the overall heating load and is the cornerstone of an energy-efficient property. No heating technology is likely to change this in our lifetime.

The Risk of Doing It Wrong: Higher Bills and Higher Carbon

If you retrospectively install a heat pump without radiator or pipe upgrades or insulation improvements, it will need higher flow temperatures to keep your home warm. This drops efficiency significantly below the figures often lauded by manufacturers in adverts.

In such cases, it can cost more to run than a good gas boiler and, because of the carbon content of the electricity used, your carbon footprint could actually be higher than sticking with gas.

This is the craziness some experience: paying more while thinking they are going green, yet not even achieving this! A professional, whole-system design avoids this entirely.

Even Bigger Savings: Switching From Oil or LPG

For off-grid homes in our area with oil or LPG, the case is often much stronger. These fuels are typically more expensive per unit of useful heat than gas.

A properly designed heat pump frequently delivers substantial running cost reductions, plus the same low-carbon benefits. All the principles above – low temperatures, emitters, insulation and siting – apply equally, or with even greater effect.

Why Choose Us?

ASME are experienced mechanical and electrical renewable specialists, serving clients across the South of England, with decades of experience in heat technology between us.

We don’t just fit a box on the wall – we design complete systems with proper heat loss calculations, emitter sizing, insulation advice and optimised siting for your specific home. Our goal is reliable performance, real savings and long-term comfort.

We handle the full job: surveys, upgrades, installation, commissioning and ongoing support.

With Boiler Upgrade Scheme grants available (£7,500 for air source heat pumps, with potential uplifts to £9,000 for certain off-gas properties), now is a great time to explore your options.

Ready to Talk to Someone?

Contact us for a no-obligation discussion or survey. We will assess your home honestly and design a system that truly saves money and reduces emissions.

Visit asme-contractors.com for more information or call our team today on 01202 081812. Let’s make your heating future efficient, reliable and affordable for the long term.

AS Mechanical and Electrical Ltd – Designed Around You

Return to top of page